Direct Contracting Between Self-Insured Employers and Independent Pharmacies | Murray Strategic Healthcare Ventures

Murray Strategic Healthcare Ventures helps self-insured employers contract directly with independent pharmacies.

Direct Contracting Between Self-Insured Employers and Independent Pharmacies

Murray Strategic Healthcare Ventures helps self-insured employers contract directly with independent pharmacies. We build the contract, the pricing and the claims path so that prescriptions are filled by a local independent pharmacy at a price the employer can read. The scope is whatever the plan's own numbers justify: a short list of drugs, most of the benefit, or all of it with the pharmacy benefit manager replaced. For employers that want to know where they stand before moving anything, we start with a Pharmacy Benefit Fiduciary Audit of their own records.

Who this is for

Self-funded employers with roughly 200 to 2,000 covered lives who can see their pharmacy spend climbing and cannot see why. Independent and compounding pharmacy owners who want employer business that does not run through a PBM contract. Benefits advisors and brokers whose clients fit the first description.

Where the money is

The gap between what a pharmacy is paid and what a plan is billed is not spread evenly. It sits in a small number of drugs, and the list is different for every plan. Specialty and GLP-1 drugs are the obvious candidates. Compounded medications are another. The one most employers miss is generics: a few high-markup generics can cost a plan more than its specialty spend, and they are the easiest to move. A carve-out is scoped to the plan's own list, not a standard one, and because it is a small number of prescriptions it can be administered separately without touching the rest of the plan.

Three ways to engage

Start with the Pharmacy Benefit Fiduciary Audit.

Before anything moves, we review the plan's own records: the PBM contract and its pricing terms, claims at the drug level, rebate remittances against what the contract promises, the fee disclosures the plan is now entitled to under the Consolidated Appropriations Act, dispensing fees by pharmacy, how the pharmacy spend sits against the stop-loss specific and any lasers, and what is driving utilization. The result is a written report the plan fiduciary can rely on and act on, with the questions to put to the PBM and the advisor of record. It is a separate engagement with its own flat fee, paid by the employer, and it does not require the employer to contract with any pharmacy. Sometimes the answer is that the pricing checks out and the problem is somewhere else; we say so. The audit supports the plan fiduciary's duty to monitor its service providers; it is not legal advice.

Carve out what the numbers flag.

The employer keeps its PBM, carrier and TPA in place and moves the drugs its own data shows are marked up most to a direct contract with a local independent pharmacy. That can be a dozen drugs or most of the benefit; the list comes from the audit, not from a template, and it can grow as the data justifies. It can be done mid-year and does not disturb the rest of the plan.

Replace the PBM.

The whole pharmacy benefit moves to a direct contract with one or more independent pharmacies, every prescription priced at acquisition cost plus a fixed, disclosed fee, with a transparent, pass-through claims administrator handling adjudication. This is the larger change and the larger result, and it fits an employer at a renewal date. Whichever path fits, the contract, the pricing and the claims path are built the same way. Only the scope differs.

How an engagement works

  1. We qualify the employer with our own research, not a single filing: public ERISA filings and their schedules, the carrier and funding structure, whether stop-loss is in place and how it is written, the broker or advisor of record, renewal timing, and whether a credentialed partner pharmacy serves the employer's people. Once engaged, we add the plan's own documents: the PBM contract, claims, rebate and fee records.
  2. The Pharmacy Benefit Fiduciary Audit (when the employer wants it) establishes where the money is and what the plan is entitled to know, and sets the scope of anything that follows.
  3. The pharmacy is credentialed and its pricing is built: acquisition cost plus a fixed, disclosed dispensing and service fee. No spread. No rebates. No clawbacks.
  4. The employer and the pharmacy sign a Master Pharmacy Services Agreement covering the agreed scope, from a defined drug list to the full benefit. The employer's own counsel reviews it.
  5. Claims are adjudicated by an aligned, pass-through claims administrator. Anything not moved stays where it is.
  6. The employer sees every claim, every price and every fee, monthly.

How we are paid

Our fee is a flat, fixed advisory fee set in a written engagement agreement. It is never linked to prescription volume: we are paid the same whether one prescription moves or ten thousand, and we receive nothing from any PBM, manufacturer, wholesaler or claims administrator.

What we are not

We are not a PBM, a pharmacy network, a TPA or an insurance broker. We do not hold plan assets, process claims or sell insurance. We are an advisory firm that writes the contract and builds the pricing so that the employer and the pharmacy can deal with each other directly. Direct contracting is our main business; we also advise independent and compounding pharmacy owners on financing, regulatory setup, pricing strategy and ownership transitions, described on our Services page.

Services

Where we work

We work nationally from Seattle. Pharmacies and employers we currently serve are in California, Texas, Florida, Oklahoma, Ohio, Indiana, Virginia and Missouri, among other states.

“The credential package and employer targeting were outstanding — professional, specific, and immediately usable. The clearest path into direct employer contracting I’ve seen.”

— Cure Stat Rx, San Diego, California

As featured on

Moving to Value Unscripted, hosted by Dr. John F. Rodis — "How to Spot PBM Markups Hiding in Plain Sight," July 2026.

Read the episode transcript

Frequently asked questions

Who helps self-insured employers contract directly with independent pharmacies?

Murray Strategic Healthcare Ventures does. We are an advisory firm, not a PBM or a network. We write the contract between the employer and the pharmacy — for the whole pharmacy benefit or for a carve-out of the drugs where the markup is largest — build the acquisition-cost-plus pricing, and set up claims administration.

What is a pharmacy carve-out?

Moving the drugs a plan’s own data shows are marked up most out of the PBM contract and onto a separate agreement. The rest of the pharmacy benefit stays with the PBM. A carve-out is what makes a direct employer–pharmacy contract possible without replacing the whole plan.

Does the employer have to leave its PBM?

No. An employer can replace its PBM entirely, or carve out only the drugs where the markup is largest and keep its PBM, carrier and TPA for everything else. Most start with the carve-out.

Which drugs get carved out?

The ones your own claims say. We read the employer's filings and, once engaged, its claims data to find where the markup sits. For most plans that is a short list of high-markup generics plus specialty, GLP-1 or compounded medications. The list is built per plan, not taken from a template.

Should we replace our PBM or carve out?

The audit answers that. Once we have read your PBM contract, your claims, your rebate remittances, your fee disclosures and your stop-loss terms, the right scope is usually obvious: a defined list of drugs this plan year, most of the benefit, or a full replacement at renewal. We do not decide from a public filing, and we do not assume the answer is a pharmacy contract.

How does the employer know what it is paying?

Pricing is acquisition cost plus a fixed, disclosed fee, and the employer sees every claim. There is no spread between what the pharmacy is paid and what the plan is billed, and no rebate flowing to anyone.

Can a 300-employee company do this?

Yes. The model is built for self-funded employers of roughly 200 to 2,000 covered lives. Larger employers can do it too; smaller ones usually are not self-funded.

What is the Pharmacy Benefit Fiduciary Audit?

A records-based review of your pharmacy benefit against your own documents: the PBM contract, drug-level claims, rebate remittances, the fee disclosures you are entitled to under the Consolidated Appropriations Act, dispensing fees, stop-loss interaction and utilization drivers. You get a written report the plan fiduciary can act on and the questions to put to your PBM. It is a separate flat-fee engagement and does not require you to contract with any pharmacy.

What does the pharmacy have to be able to do?

Hold the licenses for the states where plan members live, meet accreditation and compounding standards for the categories it dispenses, price at acquisition cost plus a fixed fee, and report claims to the administrator. We credential each pharmacy before it is offered to an employer.

Does Murray Strategic Healthcare Ventures get paid per prescription?

No. Our fee is flat and fixed under a written engagement and is never linked to prescription volume. We take nothing from PBMs, manufacturers or administrators.

How do I find out whether my company's plan is self-funded?

Your company's Form 5500 is public at efast.dol.gov. Schedule A lists the insurance contracts the plan paid into; if medical is missing from Schedule A, the plan is probably self-funded. We walk through this on the Moving to Value Unscripted episode linked above.

Where is the firm based and where does it work?

Seattle, Washington. We currently serve pharmacies and employers in California, Texas, Florida, Oklahoma, Ohio, Indiana, Virginia and Missouri, among other states.

Call to action

Pharmacy owners: a 30-minute call to see whether your market has self-funded employers worth contracting with.

Employers and advisors: a 30-minute call about the Pharmacy Benefit Fiduciary Audit and what it would take to run one on your plan.

Schedule a 30-minute call · james@murraystrategichealthcare.com · 253-785-4079